Vitamin D, magnesium and fish oil labels: what to compare
How to read and compare the labels on vitamin D, magnesium and fish oil supplements, field by field. Label facts only.
We compared published specifications and guidance. We did not test these products.
On this page
Key takeaways
- The FDA does not approve dietary supplements before they are sold.
- Every supplement carries a Supplement Facts panel; compare products using it.
- Compare the form, the amount per serving, the serving size, the count and any third-party mark.
- Talk with your doctor or pharmacist before starting a supplement, especially if you take medicines.
This guide explains how to compare supplement labels for three common products: vitamin D, magnesium and fish oil. It covers only what is printed on the label. It does not say what any nutrient does in the body, and it does not suggest an amount for you. Ask your doctor or pharmacist before starting a supplement, especially if you take any medicines.
What the FDA does and does not doLink to section: What the FDA does and does not do
The FDA says it does not have the authority to approve dietary supplements before they are marketed [1]. Makers are responsible for their products. FDA rules require a Supplement Facts panel on the label [1], which is the most useful place to compare one bottle with another. The Dietary Guidelines for Americans focus on meeting nutrient needs mainly from foods [2].
The fields to compareLink to section: The fields to compare
FormLink to section: Form
The label names the form of the ingredient. For example:
- Vitamin D is usually listed as D3 (cholecalciferol) or D2 (ergocalciferol).
- Magnesium is listed with what it is combined with, such as citrate, glycinate or oxide.
- Fish oil labels list EPA and DHA, the omega-3 fatty acids, separately from the total fish oil.
The product form (softgel, tablet, capsule, gummy or liquid) is also on the label.
Amount per servingLink to section: Amount per serving
The Supplement Facts panel lists the amount of each ingredient in one serving. Vitamin D may be shown in micrograms (mcg), International Units (IU), or both. Magnesium is shown in milligrams (mg). For fish oil, compare the EPA and DHA amounts, not only the total oil.
Serving sizeLink to section: Serving size
One serving may be one softgel or several. Two bottles with the same amount per serving can need a different number of pills to reach it.
CountLink to section: Count
The count is how many softgels, tablets or capsules are in the bottle. With the serving size, it tells you how many servings the bottle holds.
Other ingredientsLink to section: Other ingredients
The label lists other ingredients, such as the softgel shell or colors. This matters if you avoid gelatin, fish or common allergens.
Third-party marksLink to section: Third-party marks
Some labels carry a mark from an independent organization, such as USP Verified or NSF. Each organization explains on its own website what its mark covers. A mark is about the product's testing program, not about what the supplement does.
What this guide does not coverLink to section: What this guide does not cover
We do not say whether you need a supplement or how much to take. Those depend on your diet, your health and your medicines, and are questions for your doctor or pharmacist.
How we put this guide togetherLink to section: How we put this guide together
We compared what supplement labels show, using the FDA's guidance on dietary supplement labeling. We did not test these products. The links below open Amazon searches for each nutrient and form; we do not choose individual products.
Browse on Amazon
health about may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How affiliate links work
These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.
Vitamin D3 softgels
What to look for
- The amount per serving as labelled, in IU or mcg
- The count per bottle
- A USP Verified or NSF mark printed on the label
Magnesium tablets
What to look for
- The form named on the label, such as citrate, glycinate or oxide
- The amount per serving as labelled, in mg
- A USP Verified or NSF mark printed on the label
Fish oil softgels
What to look for
- The EPA and DHA amounts per serving as labelled
- The count per bottle and the serving size
- A USP Verified or NSF mark printed on the label